top of page

Feminism Did NOT Give Women Their Rights

2 hours ago
9 min read
AI-generated composite representing the likenesses of five British advocates of women’s rights: Henry Hunt, John Stuart Mill, Henry Fawcett, Jacob Bright, and Richard Pankhurst.
AI-generated composite representing the likenesses of five British advocates of women’s rights: Henry Hunt, John Stuart Mill, Henry Fawcett, Jacob Bright, and Richard Pankhurst.

The Feminist Loyalty Shakedown Breakdown


Challenge feminism’s dogma, cherished mantras, or far-fetched facts, and feminists tend to respond in one of two ways. Either they retreat into the familiar feminist motte-and-bailey,[1] or they remind you that feminism won you your rights, with the not-so-subtle implication: Wouldn’t it be a shame if something happened to those rights…


Consider this recent response from Lola on X to Bilek:

But if you want to give up your mortgage and your bank account and make marital rape legal again, then please do go ahead. Don’t forget bringing down age of consent which feminists also fought for.

Criticize feminism and apparently we ladies must surrender our bank accounts, mortgages, and the right not to be raped by our husbands.


She treats criticism of feminism as though it entails repudiating women’s legal rights. Apparently, we cannot reject the ideology without also rejecting the achievements it claims as its own. Who knew women’s rights came with an ideological loyalty clause to The Feminists? It’s so absurd. Women’s rights are not bestowed by feminism, so they cannot be revoked by The Feminists.


It is an ideological fantasy that feminism is women's indispensable protector: the belief that women's emancipation was feminism's gift and that our continued freedom depends upon allegiance to its agents and leaders. The historical mythology sustains the ideological dependency. Dismantle the mythology, and what's left? Organized feminism, essentially a protection racket in women's rights drag.


Women and girls are not obliged to be its loyal subjects.


Rights 101: A Primer


Declaring something a “right” doesn’t make it legally enforceable or culturally feasible. The former requires political institutions with the authority and coercive power to recognize, uphold, and enforce it. The latter requires sufficient social buy-in. Without it, the costs of enforcement can become prohibitive, leaving the right, at best, on paper.


Whose buy-in? Well, MEN, for starters. They made up roughly half the population, and in nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century Britain, political power was overwhelmingly concentrated in male hands. Women could not even stand for election to the House of Commons until 1918, while men dominated the judiciary and executive government. Securing women’s legal independence, property rights, suffrage, and equal protection under the law therefore required winning sufficient support among men holding political power, alongside broader social acceptance among the population, including men. Without that support, these reforms would have remained aspirations on suffragette and feminist stilts.[2]


This isn’t an argument that ruling-class men woke up one morning and generously bestowed rights upon women like manna from heaven, or that emancipation was some coordinated exercise in political patronage. It’s an acknowledgment that rights are secured through struggles, negotiations, institutions, and coalitions, not simply by declaring oneself oppressed and demanding them loudly.


Feminists campaigned. Some men opposed them, as did many women. Other men supported them, organized alongside them, championed their demands, and ultimately voted for and enacted reforms. Yet feminist revisionist history reduces this complicated struggle to a morality play of feminist heroines battling male oppressors. Male allies and dissenting women are conveniently written out of the story.


The Men in Women’s Emancipation


To keep this historical excursion manageable, I’ll confine myself to the British case. The struggle for women’s rights was neither uniquely British nor confined to feminist movements, but a comprehensive international history would take us well beyond the scope of this essay.

Nonetheless, even this abridged British account is enough to complicate the feminist historical morality play of men as a class versus women as a class.


Women’s Suffrage


In 1832, Henry Hunt, a radical reformer and MP, presented a petition to Parliament on behalf of Mary Smith, a Yorkshire woman demanding the parliamentary vote for unmarried women who met the relevant property qualifications. This was decades before the organized women’s suffrage movement emerged.


In 1866, John Stuart Mill presented the first mass women’s suffrage petition to Parliament. It had been organized by women including Barbara Bodichon, Emily Davies, and Elizabeth Garrett. The following year, Mill proposed amending the Reform Bill by replacing the word “man” with “person,” thereby extending the franchise to qualifying women. His amendment was defeated, but 73 male MPs voted in favor of women’s enfranchisement in 1867.


Among Mill’s supporters was Henry Fawcett, economist, Liberal MP, and husband of Millicent Garrett Fawcett, who would become one of Britain’s leading suffrage campaigners. Then there was Jacob Bright, another Liberal MP and longstanding advocate of women’s political rights. In 1870, he introduced the first dedicated women’s suffrage bill. By 1888, 169 MPs had signed a statement urging the government to provide parliamentary time to debate women’s suffrage. And Richard Pankhurst, a barrister and legal reformer who helped draft legislation challenging married women’s property restrictions and supported women’s enfranchisement.

Yes, that Pankhurst. The future husband of Emmeline Pankhurst.


Women’s Property Rights


In Britain, the Married Women’s Property Acts of 1870 and 1882 progressively dismantled restrictions on married women’s independent ownership and control of property, earnings, and savings. Women’s organizations campaigned for these changes. Men drafted legislation, advocated reform, and enacted the laws through Parliament.


As for bank accounts and mortgages, women were never universally prohibited from owning bank accounts until feminists supposedly secured that right for them.

Women’s participation in British banking predates modern feminism by centuries. NatWest’s historical archives document female bank customers as early as the 1660s. Married women faced genuine legal disabilities, and banks sometimes required their husbands’ authorization to open accounts. But women’s financial independence developed through successive legal, economic, and institutional changes, not through a single feminist act of liberation.


Female banking staff at the London Victoria Branch 1919
Female banking staff at the London Victoria Branch 1919

The men mentioned above, along with many more, weren’t just sympathetic behind-the-scenes spectators. They argued, organized, drafted legislation, and used their positions within political institutions to advance women’s legal and political rights


Did feminists contribute to these developments? Yes. Did they accomplish them independently of men, other reformers, and the institutions of law and government? No.


Why should acknowledging men's participation diminish women’s. It doesn’t. But it does restore the men whom the simplified feminist morality play conveniently writes out. And it exposes the historical foundation of the fantasy that feminism single-handedly delivered women’s rights.


Feminists Were Never Synonymous With Women


Many women don’t identify as feminists today. Historically, women were divided over feminist movements and the reforms they advocated. Some actively opposed demands advanced in the name of women’s emancipation. The Women’s National Anti-Suffrage League was established in Britain in 1908, with the author Mary Ward among its leading figures. In 1910, it merged with the Men’s League for Opposing Women’s Suffrage.


Feminist movements were organized, vocal political minorities that claimed to represent half the human population, including women who disagreed with their objectives. They didn’t embody Women. They claimed to speak for Women, to know what’s best for all women and girls.

There’s a difference. Loath as feminists are to acknowledge it, feminism has always had a recalcitrant “woman problem”.


Acknowledging the achievements of feminist organizations doesn’t obligate women to subscribe to whatever contemporary feminist orthodoxy happens to be circulating. I can support women’s equal standing before the law, economic independence, and bodily autonomy without genuflecting before the great pooh-bah of feminist theory: The Patriarchy. And I definitely don’t need feminism’s permission to disagree with feminists.


Who Ya Gonna Call, Ladies?


When danger strikes, who ya gonna call? When a tree crashes through your roof, you hear a prowler outside, you're being mugged, or hostilities break out? A feminist!” said no one ever.


Chances are you’ll call the police, firefighters, emergency services, or turn to the nearest passerby. And most often, the person who comes to your aid will be a man.


There’s a larger contradiction worth examining elsewhere: the moral suspicion directed at masculinity alongside the continuing expectation that men shoulder disproportionate responsibility for protection, physical risk, and sacrifice. But for now, the point is simple. Claiming to protect women and actually providing protection are not the same thing.


The Fantasy that Feminism and Feminists are Women’s Indispensable Protector


Why does the claim that feminism gave women their rights so readily become an accusation of ingratitude when a woman criticizes feminism? This narrative does more than provide a flattering account of feminist history. It sustains an ideological fantasy of feminism as women’s indispensable protector.


Psychoanalytically speaking, an ideological fantasy isn’t simply a mistaken belief about the world. It structures how subjects understand social reality and their place within it. In this case, the fantasy operates through three mutually reinforcing moves.


First, feminism imagines itself the indispensable author of women’s emancipation. The complicated history of expanding rights is condensed into a single heroic narrative: Feminism liberated Woman from The Patriarchy. The contributions of male reformers, non-feminist movements, broader political struggles, and institutional transformations are reduced, at best, to NPCs (non-player characters) in feminism’s heroic adventure.


Second, historical authorship becomes infinite dependency. If feminism gave women their rights, then women must presumably depend upon feminism to retain them. What an odd conception of freedom. The supposedly emancipated woman remains dependent upon the movement that claims to have emancipated her. She may now possess a bank account, own property, vote, work, and enjoy equal legal standing, but the movement claiming credit for those achievements expects her continued identification with it. Her independence acquires an ideological precondition.


Third, dependency becomes indebtedness. The argument shifts from feminism contributed to important reforms to after everything feminism has done for you, how dare you criticize it? Gratitude becomes an obligation that cannot be discharged. Dissent becomes betrayal. Criticism becomes an offense against the movement supposedly responsible for the critic’s freedom. Here we encounter the superegoic dimension of the fantasy that feminism freed women from the shackles of The Patriarchy. The liberator assumes the position of moral disciplinarian, demanding gratitude and treating disobedience as ingratitude.


And here lies the contradiction: an ideology that claims to have made women independent simultaneously imagines women as unable to sustain their independence without it. This is what makes the protection-racket analogy more than a sarcastic joke. The rhetorical threat isn’t that feminists can literally confiscate women’s rights. They can’t. It’s that criticism of feminism is presented as a withdrawal of allegiance to the movement supposedly responsible for securing and protecting those rights.


We liberated you. We protect you. Therefore, you owe us your loyalty. And should you withdraw that loyalty? Well, wouldn’t it be a shame if something happened to those rights…


The fantasy positions feminism as the necessary safeguard against a danger whose continued presence also justifies feminism’s claimed indispensability. And if feminism’s authority depends upon women continuing to understand themselves as vulnerable to that danger, then the promise of emancipation becomes entangled with the reproduction of dependency. The fantasy thus sustains the very dependency that the ideology claims to have overcome.


This is why dismantling feminism’s Harlequin-romance version of the history of sexual politics matters. The point isn't to just correct the historical ledger of who did what in the nineteenth century. It’s about challenging the ideological authority feminism claims through that history and, above all, destroying the fantasy that women’s continued emancipation depends upon feminism’s continued authority over them.


What We Need Is Freedom from Feminism


Feminist organizations and movements contributed to important reforms. So did men, non-feminist reformers, and broader political, economic, and institutional transformations. You cannot write men out of the history of women’s emancipation, write dissenting women out of the history of feminism, and then demand that I thank your ideology for my rights. And you certainly cannot suggest that my rights are somehow contingent upon my allegiance to your interpretation of history.


But, again, the main objective here isn’t to correct a historical distortion. It’s to kill the fantasy that feminism is women’s and girls’ indispensable protector. The fantasy that women’s rights are feminism’s gift, that criticizing feminism constitutes a betrayal of women’s interests, and that women must remain perpetually indebted to the movement that claims to have made them independent.


Do note the glaring contradiction here: a movement that claims to have liberated women cannot simultaneously demand that women remain dependent upon it. But the reality is that Women’s rights are not a feminist subscription service. I owe feminism no oath of allegiance. And neither does any other woman. Bounce.


So, who will join me in declaring independence from The Feminists, their power plays, their motte & baileys, and emotional blackmails? You literally have nothing to lose but the toxic feminism in your life.



[1] A motte-and-bailey is an argumentative maneuver in which a controversial, difficult-to-defend claim (the bailey) is defended by retreating to a more modest, defensible claim (the motte). Once the challenge has passed, the original claim is resumed. Consider Lola’s response to criticism of feminist generalizations about men: “When we talk about ‘men’, we talk about Men as a system.” The bailey attributes oppression or wrongdoing to men collectively; the motte retreats to the ostensibly more defensible claim that feminism is merely analyzing social structures, not accusing individual men. This move becomes fallacious when the structural explanation is used to deflect criticism while the original collective generalizations remain intact.

[2] This is a play on Jeremy Bentham’s famous dismissal of natural rights as “nonsense upon stilts” in Anarchical Fallacies (written in the 1790s).

Tara van Dijk is a GenX independent scholar aka overeducated gig worker. You can read more of Tara’s critiques of feminism here. You can support her by subscribing to her Substack, by buying her a coffee, or via paypal. She is on X @TaravoidDijk.

Jennifer Bilek is an investigative journalist who has tracked the funding of the gender industry for over a decade. She is author of the The 11th Hour, a platform highlighting the connections between technology, transsexualism, and transhumanism. Her research into the philanthropic backers of the gender industry has been utilized for legal briefs, and platformed in myriad publications, films, and other media in the US and internationally. She has appeared on The Megyn Kelly Show, Steven Bannon’s War Room, and James Patrick’s Big Picture, and on various other platforms and podcasts. She has been featured in films such as No Way Back (2023), Gender Transformation (2023), and The Gender Delusion (2023). Her work has been published in numerous books and magazines, among which: First Things, Tablet, Human Events, The Spectator World, The Federalist, The American Mind, and in the anthology Female Erasure. She is the author of Transsexual Transgender Transhuman: Dispatches From the 11th Hour Now, also available in Portuguese. Jennifer can be found on X: @bjportraits and @11thblog.



 
 
 

Comments


blacksand.png
Your donations make this research possible - Support the 11th Hour Blog!
Donate with PayPal
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
gettr.png
JOIN THE 11TH HOUR MAILING LIST

Thanks for subscribing!

Jen 11th hour logo 2.png
gettr.png
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon

© 2020 Jennifer Bilek/The 11th Hour Blog. All rights reserved.

bottom of page